Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Real brief homework

Besides working on your rough draft and visual argument (ahem), try and bring to section some sentences that are giving you trouble. We'll do sentence revision.

Monday, February 18, 2008

Homework for this week

Contrary to what I told a few of you, I do want you to bring in a full rough draft to section. We'll do some peer-review of it. I won't collect it, but make sure it's not, you know, 3 pages.

Also, I want you to do the organizational exercise outlined on the syllabus. It'll take you 30 seconds. Just copy-and-paste the topic sentences (frequently, but not universally, the first sentence) of each paragraph into a new paragraph. The first sentence of the new paragraph should be the topic sentence of your first paragraph; the second sentence of the new paragraph should be the topic sentence of your second paragraph, and so on. Bring that into class as well.

Alright, see you all on Wednesday. And, Happy President's Day!

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

General question thread

Hello everybody!

Just wanted to put up a thread so you guys would have a place to put questions and get answers.

I'll try and answer questions myself, but I'll wait for other people to put their two cents in first; frequently, formulating an answer to a question helps the answerer as much as the asker.

Feel free to be as specific as you like in asking questions. Even if the question seems pretty specific, the answer I give is likely one that other students can generalize. Plus, you're not all unique snowflakes (contrary to what your elementary school teachers may have said), so if you've got a question, someone else likely has the same question as well.

Finally, if you're embarrassed (although you shouldn't be), you can always ask question anonymously.


So, any questions?

Monday, February 11, 2008

Schedule (combined with 11 AM section)

Tuesday
10-Chris Lonner
10:15 Nichole Colonna
10:30 - Yesie Choi
10:45
11 Jaylene Nguyen
11:15
11:30 - Mackenzie Guinon
11:45- Andy
12

Thursday
9 Jenny
9:15 Adriana Sota
9:30 Kenny Kashiwada
9:45
10 Jed Banayat
10:15 April Onstott
10:30 Jasmin Eshragh
10:45 - Jessica Liss
11Sylvain
11:15 nicole e
11:30 Trisha Rama
11:45 Ruslan Balagansky
12 David Guerra
12:15Stacie Walsh
12:30- Spencer
12:45 Lacey Dowden
1-Nicole Gilmore
1:15Daniel Ozeki
1:30 Goldie Choi
1:45 Tracy Gerona
2 - Jaron Lum
2:15 - Stephanie Simpson
2:30
2:45
3
3:15
3:30 - Richard Wang
3:45

Tuesday, February 5, 2008

Just a reminder

Your chaos drafts for this week can draw on the chaos drafts from last week.

Most of the writing should be new, but feel free to draw inspiration, or even a sentence or two, from last week's work.

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Homework clarification

Two main parts:

(A) Ignore the McCloud assignment for now (but do the reading, which is online on WebCT). We'll do the assignment in section.

(B) What's a Chaos Draft, Dave?

Well, a chaos draft is largely what it sounds like. It's a chaotic draft, whose purpose is to simply pour the contents of your head out onto paper, so that you can take a look at what's in there. It's chaotic in that you should always be moving forward while writing one. No correcting, no looking back. Just write, and try to write quickly. It can be hard to do this, so don't be surprised if you need to monitor yourself. It's basically impossible to focus one of these, so just keep issues of power and language in mind when you start, and if you get stuck, fall back on those (e.g. ask yourself what certain phrases did, rather than what the words meant).

Questions?

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Syllabus

Sixth Practicum Writing
Culture, Art, Technology 125

Winter 2008


“We must remove the mask, [for] everyone has within [her]self the entire human condition. [We do this by] interrogating our ignorance [and] thinking ourselves through.” ---- Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592)


Instructor: Dr. Linda Strauss, Dr. Ebonee Williams
Teaching Assistants: Roger Ngim, Jessica Cole, David Leitch, Ryan Canlas, Matt McGarvey, DJ Campbell

Overview of Practicum Reflective Writing at Sixth College

The practicum program is intended to further your academic development, civic engagement, and personal growth. The Practicum Reflective Writing course (CAT 125) aims to foster this advanced growth and development by deepening your understanding of your own ability to participate effectively as well as creatively in a community. Reflection is integrated throughout the entire practicum experience, but in CAT 125 you will be extending and deepening your reflection while refining your abilities to communicate, in writing and visually, what you have learned to a variety of audiences.

The CAT 125 course therefore has three main learning goals:
1. You will learn or refine exploratory, analytical, and persuasive writing techniques
2. You will assess the extent of and the constraints upon your own effectiveness in bringing about positive change in a given community
3. You will develop habits supporting on-going self-reflection and social and cultural analysis

CAT 125 Course Description
The class is designed to have a weekly one-hour large group lecture section and a weekly two-hour small group workshop/discussion section. Attendance at both lecture and section is required. Lecture will introduce overarching ideas, analytical strategies and examples of effective argumentation. Section will serve as a forum for comparison of practicum experiences and insights, discussions of readings and lectures as well as for inquiry-promoting exercises, writing exercises and workshops developing and peer reviewing written and visual assignments.

Aims:
Your primary task in this course is to reflect in writing upon how your understanding of yourself and your world has been affected by your experiences in your practicum project, within the larger context of your education at UCSD. You will have the opportunity to consider how your discoveries about who you are, what you have learned about your capacities for effecting change in the world, and your own current plans for your future fit together. You will accomplish this task mainly by composing an extended reflective essay, though you will also be making use of other forms of writing and visual exploration. This reflective essay is not the same thing as a report on your practicum project and its results, which you may or may not have already written as part of completing the Practicum Project. Traditionally, essays are written not simply to communicate, but to probe and explore subjects that both the author and the audience do not fully understand. The assumption underlying the reflective practicum essay is that we ourselves, together with our abilities to effect meaningful change in the world, are among the things we do not automatically or fully understand without sustained intellectual effort. In asking you to focus intellectual effort on a lengthy exploratory process of drafting and redrafting a reflective essay, we aim to help you achieve a clearer and more profound understanding of yourself. This entails considering the assumptions and choices that you made, and the effectiveness of both your choices and your actions. A further aim is for you to understand more fully how your identity, your values, choices and actions, and their subsequent results are a consequence of the culture and subcultures that you normally inhabit and in which you completed your project. An additional aim is for you to begin to perceive how your own identity, intentions, values, choices, and actions intersect in both positive and negative ways with those of other people as we collectively continue to shape both the physical world around us and the cultures and subcultures through which we live, work and find meaning. A final aim is for you to improve your ability to express and communicate your discoveries in effective ways, especially through writing, to a variety of audiences.
Means:
In this course we expect you to place your practicum experience in a larger intellectual, social, and cultural context, which may include thinking about the ways in which it was informed by art and technology. You will draw on your own experiences as you use readings, discussion, writing, visual and possibly auditory expression to discern patterns, pose questions, and probe possible answers to significant cultural and social concerns related to you, your practicum and your larger goals and intentions for your life. You will be exploring such issues as how our various human motives and intentions, our hopes, expectations, beliefs and assumptions, our relative statuses and access to resources, and other such basic concerns affect our abilities to bring about change and understanding in ourselves, our communities, and the larger world. The lectures offer guidance, inspiration and examples of how to conduct this kind of inquiry; the readings offer further examples and models of effective writing as well as theoretical approaches to cultural analysis. Sections provide opportunities to compare experiences, to discuss course concepts drawn from readings and lectures, and will offer opportunities for workshop-writing and peer review. Course tools for personal reflection include the following components:

Analysis of your practicum project log or journal
Blog posts
Analytical exercises:
Three short narratives
Alienation exercise
Visual argument
Letter
Reflective Essay:
Chaos Draft
Final Draft
Abstract/Resume entry

The ultimate goal of the CAT 125 reflective essay is to achieve a clearer and more profound understanding of your own human identity and of how that identity-- with its attendant sense of meaning, values and purpose—is at once a consequence and cause of the cultures you inhabit and in which you work. The method we ask you to practice is to pose questions and to probe answers about yourself and others with respect to motives and intentions, hopes and expectations and effectiveness, beliefs and assumptions, and other such basic concerns that inform our individual consciousness. This will allow you to explore the hypothesis that much of what we think of as our personal identity originates, for better or worse, from our situation within cultures.

Opening Questions for beginning your reflection:
With your Practicum in mind and as a prelude to composing your CAT 125 essay, you might pose to yourself a variety of questions, such as:
• What were your motives for choosing your particular Practicum project?
• What were your intentions, your aims and your hopes?
• What were your experiences?
• What patterns do you discern when you review your Practicum Project log-book or journal?
• What sort of obstacles or challenges did you encounter that you did not expect? How did you handle those challenges? What do you think was the source of those challenges?
• What did you achieve, and how did that compare to what you intended?
• What sorts of changes did you make or experience during your practicum?
• What do your experiences reveal to you about other people, or about the nature of our society or other societies?
• What do your experiences and your reflections about them reveal to you about yourself?
• Have your vocational (in the small `v’ or big `V’ sense) goals changed at all as a consequence of this experience?

Your essay should not focus exclusively, however, on your Practicum; while some description of your Practicum may be helpful, what you describe should serve as a springboard for deeper examination of subjects you judge to be significant in the larger patterns of your life, education, and the various cultures you inhabit


Grading

Attendance and participation 10%
Reading quizzes/commentaries 10%
Blog entries 5%
Narrative exercise 5%
“Defamiliarization” exercise 5%
Reflective essay exploratory “Chaos draft” 15%
Visual Argument 10%
Letter 10%
Reflective Essay Final draft 25%%
Abstract or resume entry & complete portfolio 5%
You will create a final electronic portfolio containing copies of your Practicum Proposal, your Practicum Journal or Log, any final product for your practicum project, and copies of all the above CAT 125 assignments (except for blog postings). We highly recommend that you keep one electronic copy for your own use when you turn in the portfolio.

Attendance Policy: One of our goals is to cultivate your ability and desire to engage one another in serious and sincere intellectual discourse. For this purpose we require your consistent attendance in lecture and discussion, each of which occurs just once a week. We will deduct a full letter grade for more than two unexcused absences (lecture, section or combination of both lecture and section). Also, for the purpose of encouraging promptness and, with it, respect for your fellow students, teaching assistants and instructors, attendance will generally be taken at the beginning of a class.
ACADEMIC INTEGRITY
You are expected to uphold the standards of academic integrity in all your work.
All work that you submit for credit in CAT is expected to be your own original work, created specifically for this class. Where you are making appropriate use of the work of another person, which may include brief quotations, photographs or drawings, charts, special information, specific arguments, etc., you must credit the author of that work by using appropriate and complete citations. (See below, “Using and Citing Sources” for guidance on how to do this.) If you choose to include in your CAT assignments any data, information, argument or artwork that you have produced for another course, you should identify it as such with an appropriate self-citation, and it should in no way constitute the bulk of the assignment that you are submitting for credit in CAT.
UCSD has a university-wide Policy on Integrity of Scholarship, which can be found online at http://www-senate.ucsd.edu/manual/appendices/app2.htm. All students must read and be familiar with this Policy. All suspected violations of academic integrity will be reported to UCSD’s Academic Integrity Coordinator. Students found to have violated UCSD’s standards for academic integrity may receive both administrative and academic sanctions. Administrative sanctions may extend up to and include suspension or dismissal, and academic sanctions may include failure of the assignment or failure of the course.
Specific examples of prohibited violations of academic integrity include the following: (although this should in no way be considered an exhaustive list of examples):
Academic stealing refers to the theft of exams or exam answers, of papers or take-home exams composed by others, and of research notes, computer files, or data collected by others.
Academic cheating, collusion, and fraud refer to having others do your schoolwork or helping or allowing them to present your work as their own; using unauthorized materials during exams; inventing data or bibliography to support a paper, project, or exam; purchasing tests, answers, or papers from any source whatsoever; submitting (nearly) identical papers to two classes. Helping other students to cheat or steal is also cheating.
Misrepresenting personal or family emergencies or health problems in order to extend deadlines and alter due dates or requirements is another form of academic fraud. Claiming you have been ill when you were not, claiming that a family member has been ill or has died when that is untrue are some examples of unacceptable ways of trying to gain more time than your fellow students have been allowed in which to complete assigned work.
Please do not ask or allow friends or family members to write or substantially edit your work. That is both a violation of academic integrity and a short-circuiting of the learning process.
Plagiarism refers to the use of another’s work without full acknowledgment, whether by suppressing the reference, neglecting to identify direct quotations, paraphrasing closely or at length without citing sources, spuriously identifying sources

STUDENTS WITH SPECIAL NEEDS:
Students with physical or learning disabilities should first work with UCSD’s Office for Students with Disabilities to obtain current documentation, then contact instructor and TA’s to arrange appropriate academic accommodations. This should be accomplished as soon in the quarter as possible. To be fair to all students, no individual accommodations will be made unless the student first presents the proper documentat
quotations or data, or cutting and pasting the work of several (usually unidentified) authors into a single undifferentiated whole.
Readings: Readings in this class will include examples of: exploratory writing, effective rhetoric, relevant style, cultural analysis, and exemplary student work.

Texts:
CAT 125 Winter 2008 Course Reader
Peter John, ed. Praxis: A Collection of CAT 125 Student Essays
Strunk and White, Elements of Style
Receipt of this syllabus constitutes an acknowledgment that you are responsible for understanding and acting in accordance with UCSD guidelines on academic integrity.

Course Schedule
Week 1: The Purpose of the Practicum Essay

LECTURE: Define and describe service learning and civic engagement in the context of culture, community, and the practicum projects just completed. Offer an overview of the structure of the class and what our learning goals are, detailing the importance of essay writing as a process of discovery, letter writing, drafting, visual argument, dialogue, peer-review, and audience.
The Purpose of an Essay (“Interrogating one’s ignorance,” Montaigne).
Probing for an understanding of yourself in relation to the world, while resolutely asserting “the right not to know what you do not know.”

SECTION: Draw from student journals to share student practicum project, intentions, and memorable practicum experiences detailing community, challenges, and achievements. Explain and discuss the multiple narratives exercise, using Orwell as the initial example and then drawing examples from students.

READ (for week 1): Montaigne, Orwell; Booth; Minor, Linton
Post: Short description of your practicum intentions, process and what you think you accomplished
COMPOSE: (for week 2): Multiple Narrative Exercise--Create three different narratives about your Practicum experience as you imagine it to fit into the larger patterns of your education and life. (Narratives should explore different perspectives on the same experience and might differ in tone, central claim, emphasis, pace or temporal strategy, or point of view, for example). Each narrative should be more than one paragraph but less than one page

Week 2: Techniques of Analytical Reflection: Defamiliarization, Comparative Perspective and Sixth College approach to analysis of Culture, Art, and Technology

LECTURE:: Review core sequence approach to culture, art, technology. Review uses of visual rhetoric. Introduce visual analysis of intersection and interactions of cultural forces, communities, infrastructure, artifacts, and individual actions. Link analysis of forces to practicum projects.

1] The main ideas of CAT (Models and metaphors for thinking about CAT (eg., pyramid, concentric circles; Cartesian analogy)
2] The idea of a “diagram of forces” (D’Arcy Thompson)
3] The purpose of defamiliarization and reflection (“to make the familiar strange”)



SECTION: Share, compare and discuss multiple narratives. Can the incompatible be made compatible? Which combination of interpretations is the most valid?
In preparation for the defamiliarization exercise, explore the cultural dimensions of your own and fellow student’s identity and experiences with specific reference to main ideas of Culture, Art and Technology and with attention to the task of seeing oneself and ones “human built world” (T. Hughes) as so many cultural artifacts, artifacts that are a manifestations of forces, some but not all of which we understand.
Analyze and, if possible, diagram the cultural forces at work in student’s own projects.
Address the Minor reading and the defamiliarization exercise for week 3.

READ (for week 2): Geertz, Dissanayake, Pacey
Blog Post: Short discussion of the major obstacles and challenges you encountered during your practicum and your own role in creating or exacerbating these challenges or obstacles
COMPOSE: (for week 3): “Defamiliarization” exercise: create a 3 page document in which you explore yourself and your peers within the context of your Practicum as if they are unfamiliar cultural artifacts. Your document should demonstrate that you grasp the main ideas of CAT (see, Geertz, Dissanyake, Pacey) by pointing to those experiences from your Practicum which best exemplify the ideas explored in the lecture and in the readings.


Week 3: Language as a “Diagram of Forces”

LECTURE: Discuss how the use of language expresses author’s values, and how those values are cultural expressions. Explore examples of how to power relationships are expressed and reinforced through words and language use. Key terms and expressions encountered in students’ practicum experiences will be shared, analyzed, and evaluated.
1) Reading language as a cultural artifact; words as “diagrams of forces”
2) Metaphorical foundations of language and thought
3) The idea behind Chaos drafting explained.

SECTION: Brainstorm how language was used during practicum experience, with particular attention to those words, symbols, gestures that seem most salient in revealing the dynamics of power in your practicum experience.. How does language represent relationships, power structures, values and how does it influence subsequent choices and actions? Explore examples of the use of language and gestures in your own experience and how they might be “read” to reveal their hidden or “encoded” meanings.
Study McCloud and discuss how students might visual render the forces pertinent to their own experiences.
If there is time, for a portion of the section also share and discuss student examples of the defamiliarization exercise.


READ (for week 3): McCloud; Hebdige, Hochshild, Ewen, Donor #15, Pollan, Lakoff, Johnson, Frost, Jefferson

COMPOSE: (for week 4): Using McCloud as your model, and using as many or as few frames as you deem necessary, while focusing on one or several specific experiences, diagram as vividly as you can the power relations you perceived or experienced in the course of your education and your Practicum.
Begin Chaos Draft 3 pages, written over the course of two timed sessions of 45 minutes each, without hesitation or correction. Focus on issues having to do with uses and distribution of power, status, access to resources, trust or prestige with respect to your practicum experience.


Week 4: Vocation

LECTURE: : Examine how we develop as individuals, the forces, communities and values that shape who we are and how we see the world. Introduce such terms as: vocation, freedom, career, community, individual/cultural values. Review use of chaos draft for generating alternative perspectives.

1) Interplay of X and Y
2) Career or Vocation? How these are framed in different cultures.

SECTION: Explore what the students’ own practicum experiences reveal about themselves, their cultural assumptions and their choices. How have you been shaped? Is there something you feel “called” to do? Who is “calling,” and for what purpose? How can you know? Are there things you feel strongly that you are not “called” to do?
Also, explore some of the subject possibilities for your second Chaos drafts suggested by your various preliminary composition exercises and.your initia Chaos draft.
Also, discuss how one might usefully integrate information from ones journal.

READ. (for week 4): Weber, Hughes, King, Steingraber


COMPOSE: for week 5: Chaos Draft: increase chaos draft to 10-12 pages , working in at least three timed writing sessions.

Week 5. Visual Argumentation/Writing as a process of design
Guest Lecture: Tara Knight, M.F.A., filmmaker
Section: NOTE: All sections will meet this week only in Smart Classroom (“The Bridge” Pepper Canyon Hall 240)
Compose: Create a visual argument that effectively expresses a major claim that you wish to make in your reflective essay. Complete Chaos draft (producing four to five new pages this week)

Schedule: one-on-one meetings with TA for discussion in 6th or 7th week

Week 6: On Force, Focus and Coherence in Your Essay

LECTURE: The Essay as a Scalpel or a Laserr
COMPOSE (for week 6): Begin composing final draft by first identifying and then elaborating those portions of Chaos Draft most central to your main topic. Make notes, highlights, organizational marks and analytical diagrams on hard copy of Chaos draft. Refer to Visual argument for guidance in establishing your overall organizational strategy for final essay.

Revision plan for essay. Possibilities for the subject of your essay as suggested by the content of your Chaos Draft. Discovering and Inventing Order.

SECTION: Peer Review of first Chaos drafts. Exchange copy of “chaos” draft with another student. Submit a second copy of chaos draft to your instructor.
What is worth elaborating on from the chaos draft into the final essay? Structuring chaos draft (choosing perspective and content).
Teaching Assistant will comment on what passages in your “chaos” draft might be worth elaborating into a final essay, with particular attention to how you might draw out some themes of Culture, Art and Technology.
General discussion about the possible subject, themes, organization, and style of your final draft. How might one combine these various and conflicting narrative structures into a single coherent essay?
:
COMPOSE (for week 7): Attempt, as you proceed toward the final, polished draft of your essay, to identify the thread of coherence binding together all the paragraphs by composing and recomposing a single paragraph made up entirely of your topic sentences.




Week 7: Persuasion, Voice and Style

LECTURE: Establishing consistency in style, structure, imagery, and intent. Organizing and revising sentences and paragraphs.
1) Prelude and brief retrospective: Philosophers and Rhetoricians; Scientists and Politicians
2) Who, Why, How to Persuade? Audience and intention. Examples of persuasive rhetoric, especially in letter format.
3) Relevance of letter writing to bringing closure to practicum experience.

Section: Selecting audience, examining rhetorical choices in preparation for composing letter.

Also: Peer Review of about your penultimate draft. In preparation for discussion. Attempt to identify the thread of coherence binding together all the paragraphs by composing a single paragraph made up entirely of your topic sentences. Exchange this paragraph along with a copy of your penultimate draft with a fellow student and use class time to examine its strengths and weaknesses. As part of peer review, consider the author’s treatment of CAT themes; also, consider the essay through the lens of Strunk and White. Select good and bad sentences from your essay-in-progress to bring to section, including multiple drafts of several sentences you have tried to improve by revision. Distinguish between sentences that might benefit from grammatical revision and those that might benefit from stylistic revision (see Strunk and White).


READ: Strunk/White “The Elements of Style.”



Compose (for week 8): Compose letter; also, complete final version of visual argument





Week 8: Concision


Lecture: 1) The meaning of clarification (Ex: sentence revision)
2) Examples of Verbal and Visual Concision
3) How to condense one’s writing effectively. PowerPoint techniques.


Section: Peer review of letter
Peer review of final version of Visual Abstract
Audition for in-lecture presentations


READ: Strunk and White


DISCUSSION/REVISING:
Also: Compression exercise: Identify at least five sentences that would be improved by being shortened by a third or a half, and then rewrite them. COMPOSE (for week 9): continue composing final draft; attempt once again to identify the thread of coherence binding together all the paragraphs by composing a single paragraph made up entirely of your topic sentences.



Week 9: : Essays, Identity and the Presentation of Self

Section: Dialogue about how practicum experience fit into your general education and future plans



Week 10: In-class presentations


Final essay (Hard and electronic copy of essay (approx. 10-12 pages), visual abstract, and letter due in discussion)


Section: to be announced




Writing Criteria

An "A" paper:

• Is based on the perception of possibilities in its subject; (possibly) takes a chance--and wins.
• Possesses highly efficient organization.
• Is not just accurate but felicitous in expression.
• Has effective rhythm and sentence emphasis.
• Has an individual style or "voice."
• Studiously avoids jargon and cliches.

A "B" paper:

• Has an effective organization
• Has rhetorical emphasis.
• Uses clear sentence structure and correct diction; sometimes, however, sentences may lack variety or power, and sometimes word choice may be proper but dull.
• Shows a command of the rules of grammar and punctuation.

A "C" paper:

• Does not show a pattern of major grammatical mistakes (it often reveals, however, a less than perfect understanding of the rules). Essays with major, consistent grammatical problems should not be considered "C" work, regardless of their content.
• Has at least a fundamental organization.
• Precisely stated or fully supported.
• Often shows a lack of economy: unnecessary words in a sentence, unnecessary sentences in a paragraph.
• Often has a "voice" that sounds anonymous, lifeless, unengaging.
• Sentences may often be stilted and laborious.

A "D" paper:

• Lacks an organizing principle.
• Does not advance beyond the very obvious.
• Is frequently unclear.
• Shows a pattern of major grammatical mistakes.

An "F" paper:
• Fails to address the assigned topic, or shows no commitment to facts or text.
• Shows a fundamental ignorance of grammatical rules.
• Is so poorly phrased that its argument can be understood only with difficulty.
• Is plagiarized. (Plagiarism is the use of someone else's thoughts, words, or ideas without acknowledgement; whether you do this intentionally or unintentionally, it is still plagiarism).

(Note: any one of these four characteristics justifies an "F," and plagiarism** justifies either failure of an assignment or of an entire course.)

* These criteria are drawn from the standards used in the Revelle Humanities Department, University of California, San Diego (reproduced here by permission of Stephen Cox).

**For a more elaborate explanation of plagiarism please consult either, Brenda Spatt, Writing from Sources (NY, 1983), the MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers, Diana Hacker, A Writer's Reference (St. Martin's, 4th ed.), or any introductory English text, or see me or your writing instructor.